Jump to Navigation

Surgical Complications Rate Correlates with Peer Rating of Skill

Photo of Armand Leone

Surgical complications correlate with a surgeon's skills as rated by his or her surgical peers. A study in the New England Journal of Medicine showed that the complication rates for bariatric surgeons were 3 to 5 times higher for surgeons rated in the lowest quartile (the lowest rated 25% of surgeons evaluated) compared with the highest quartile (the top rated 25% of surgeons evaluated). Twenty bariatric surgeons in Michigan sent in a representative videotape of a laparoscopic gastric bypass they performed and had their surgical skills evaluated by a panel of surgeons who did not know the identity of the surgeons on the videotape. Peer rating of surgical skills was accurate in so far as those surgeons who rated high had surgical complications of 5% compared with surgeons who rated low with complication rates of 15%. The increased surgical complications included leak, obstruction, infection and hemorrhage.

Variations in surgical skill and outcomes may never be eliminated. However just like athletes, deliberate coaching, training and monitoring are essential to improving performance. Video review is a method that provides beneficial one-on-one surgeon coaching. In Michigan, bariatric surgeons now watch each other operate during on-site visits and can watch on-line videos of surgeons with superior skills. The NEJM study had implications for surgical specialty board organizations. Traditional methods for ensuring surgical competence, such as continuing medical education and submission of personal surgical statistics when applying for recertification, do not adequately identify those surgeons whose techniques are below average.

Surgical errors are a major cause of iatrogenic patient injuries and increase health care costs. Surgical societies need to use peer review to assess the competency of surgeons who they certify. Patients should also ask surgeons about their experience with the proposed surgery, as well as what the surgeon's personal statistics and surgical complications rates are. Given the three fold difference in adverse events between surgeons rated in the top quartile compared with those in the bottom quartile, a peer review monitoring process should be implemented.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information
disclaimer.

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

close

Privacy Policy

"The mission of Britcher Leone, LLC is to unite the professional disciplines of medicine and law to help the victims of physicians' malpractice and serious personal injury restore their future and the future of their families." RSS FindLaw Network
Verdicts & Settlements
  • $1,237,004 Verdict for Failure to Properly Treat
  • $42 Million Dollar Vaccine Injury Structured Settlement
  • $5.7 Million Obstetrical Malpractice Structured Settlement
  • $3.8 Million Present Value Pediatric Urological Surgery Settlement
  • $3.38 Million Gross Medical Malpractice Verdict
  • $1.65 Million Present Value Spinal Surgery Settlement
  • $5.2 Million Obstetrical Malpractice Structured Settlement
  • $40 Million Vaccine Structured Award
  • $19 Million Vaccine Structured Award
  • $2.5 Million Failure to Timely Diagnose Breast Cancer Verdict
  • $16 Million Obstetrical Malpractice Structured Settlement
  • $13.6 Million Obstetrical Malpractice Structured Settlement
  • $3.5 Million Resort Negligence Settlement
  • $60 Million Flu Vaccine Structured Settlement
  • $2 Million Wrongful Birth/Wrongful Life Settlement
  • $3.5 Million Present Value Wrongful Death Settlement
  • $1.59 Million Medical Malpractice Judgment
  • $800,000 Recovery Failure to Treat Eye Infection and Vision Loss
  • $1.35 Million Wrongful Death Settlement
  • $1.2 Million Failure to Provide Adequate Security Settlement
  • $850,000 Settlement for Brachial Plexus/Shoulder Dystocia Injury
  • $1 Million Podiatric Malpractice Judgment
  • $863,000 Orthopedic Malpractice Judgment
  • $850,000 Radiology Malpractice Settlement
  • $800,000 Cardiology Malpractice/Wrongful Death Settlement
View All Verdicts
Google+ LinkedIn Uniting Medicine & Law | Rebuilding Your Future